Created  with
 db QwikSite Personal
Not for Commercial Use     

News More Info.

News More Info.
Article Date01-09-2009
Record TYPENews
Article TOPICAgent Orange/Purple
Article TitleAgent Orange Gleaner Article 1
Article ContentThe Canadian military will be looking in the wrong place if they conduct more soil tests
at a CFB Gagetown herbicide dump this summer, says an Agent Orange expert.
Dr. Wayne Dwernychuk has spent years studying Agent Orange's after-effects in
Vietnam and is the senior vice-president of Hatfield Consultants Ltd., a British
Columbia-based research company.

He said he has seen countless cases of birth defects and other ailments in the Vietnamese,
decades after Agent Orange and other dioxin-contaminated herbicides were used during
the U.S. military's Operation Ranch Hand in the Vietnam War.
Dioxin, called one of the most toxic substances known to man, has possible links to
cancer, reports the U.S. Institute of Medicine.

The U.S. dumped Agent Orange on the dense Vietnamese jungle, trying to clear enemy
hiding places in the brush, at a rate of three gallons per acre.
There's still dioxin being found in Vietnamese soil, Dwernychuk said.
According to a 1968 U.S. military technical memorandum, three gallons per acre was
also the spray rate at CFB Gagetown as part of a land-clearing project.
If it can still be found in Vietnam, it could still be found at CFB Gagetown, he said.
""I'm sure if you take a soil sample from an area that was sprayed consistently, I would
suspect you could find something there,"" Dwernychuk said. ""Depending on the amount of
erosion and the amount of movement that would have occurred over the years, I suspect
there is some residual level.""

A 1985 soil test done at a CFB Gagetown site, where empty barrels of herbicide were
buried, showed no signs of dioxin contamination.
But those test results are problematic for two reasons, Dwernychuk said.
One, the tests were probably conducted with low-resolution detection equipment.
Two, it doesn't say anything about the soils that were sprayed in 1966 and 1967.
""The sampling of the Gagetown container dump site has no bearing whatsoever on the
dioxin contamination question related to Agent Orange (and) Purple applications on the
base,"" Dwernychuk said. ""Chemical data generated through that exercise in no way
removes concerns related to the potential for present day dioxin contamination on the
experimental plots used by the US military.""
But until the testing is done, he said, it's unclear how high the concentrations would be or
if it 's st ill harmful to humans.

On Tuesday, Karen Ellis, Defence assistant deputy minister of infrastructure and
environment, quoted the Canadian Force's Surgeon-General and U.S. studies that said it's
likely sunlight degraded any herbicide lingering in the air from the helicopter spraying.
""The vast majority of Agent Orange sprayed in Gagetown would have been absorbed by
the forest canopy or would have broken down in sunlight, with very little reaching the
ground,"" she said in Ottawa.
""It is extremely unlikely that individuals travelling through the Gagetown test area, even
shortly after spraying, could have received an exposure to Agent Orange of any health
While dioxin can degrade in the presence of ultraviolet light, such as from the sun, it's
still a long process and takes longer than a few days, Dwernychuk said.
If it gets beneath the soil, away from UV light, virtually no degradation takes place. Even
regularly tilled Vietnam farm soil shows dioxin contamination, he said.
He called the comment about sunlight degrading the herbicide at CFB Gagetown as ""the
most idiotic I have heard on the whole affair.""
""UV will assist in the destruction of dioxin, but it takes quite a while,"" Dwernychuk said.
""It's not a rapid process.""
As dioxin is a very stable molecule that can linger for decades after its use, Dwernychuk
said enough doubt exists to warrant a soil test.
Using today's high-resolution detection equipment, it's even possible dioxin could be
found at the dumpsite, he said.

Dr. Coreen Hamilton is the scientific director at AXYS Analytical, another B.C.-based
company that has done dioxin tests for departments of both the Canadian and American
governments. She confirmed low-resolution technology was being used in 1985. She said AXYS was among the first Canadian companies to get a high-resolution scanner a few years after
""It's likely these analyses, if they were done in 1985 or earlier, were using the older
technology,"" she said. ""If they were done nowadays, things not detectable in those days
might now be detectable.""
High-resolut ion equipment has detection limits 100 times lower than low-resolut ion,
Hamilton said.
Where results were once measured in parts per trillion, she said they're now being
measured in fractions of one part per trillion.
""Therefore it is possible that analyses conducted with the newer technology will find
concentrations of contaminants when analyses by the old technology did not,"" she said.

So far, the military hasn't committed to further testing.A public meeting with National Defence will take place at 1:30 p.m. Thursday at the base auditorium, building F-12.
SourceThe Fredericton Daily GleanerNews, Thursday, Jun
Source URL 
Related External Link 
Additional Link 
Periodical Issue
Periodical No 
VVi Contributor